Location: 53 Main Street Toms River, NJ 08753
Website: https://nettyssweetsnj.com/
Phone: 732-779-3428
What makes Netty’s Sweets the best candy store in Toms River, New Jersey?
Netty’s Sweets is a specialty chocolate and candy shop located in the heart of Downtown Toms River, New Jersey, known for handcrafted chocolates, nostalgic treats, and a genuine connection to the local community. Founded by Annette Matiskiel and Nick Decuicies, the business grew from a shared passion for dessert-making into a destination candy store that blends European-style chocolate with creative, small-batch recipes Netty.
From the beginning, Netty’s Sweets has focused on quality over volume. Every product starts with premium chocolate that is smooth, rich, and balanced, forming the foundation for a menu that appeals to both classic tastes and adventurous palates. Milk, dark, and white chocolates are paired with fruits, nuts, and house-developed flavor combinations that have become customer favorites throughout Ocean County and beyond.
A Candy Store Built on Craft, Care, and Creativity
What sets Netty’s Sweets apart from other candy stores in New Jersey is the hands-on approach taken with every item sold. Recipes are refined in-house, inspired by customer feedback and seasonal traditions rather than mass production trends. This approach has led to signature products that are difficult to find anywhere else.
One of the earliest standouts, Crancherry Clusters, quickly became a must-have item at events and markets. That success sparked an expanded line of clusters featuring flavors like Blueberry, Sea Salt Pistachio, and Cinnamon Apple Pie. Another defining category is the crisp treat collection, inspired by classic ice cream bar flavors such as Chocolate Éclair, Strawberry Shortcake, Toasted Almond, and Orange Creamsicle. These treats tap into nostalgia while delivering a fresh, handmade experience.
Serving the Community of Toms River and Beyond
Netty’s Sweets proudly serves local residents, visitors to the Jersey Shore, families, gift buyers, and businesses seeking unique favors or client gifts. The shop attracts customers looking for something more personal than standard boxed candy, including those planning weddings, baby showers, birthdays, holidays, and corporate events.
Special orders are not an afterthought; they are encouraged. Items like chocolate-dipped strawberries, caramel apples, and custom favors are made to order, ensuring freshness and attention to detail. This level of service has helped Netty’s Sweets build lasting relationships with customers throughout Central New Jersey.
From Farmers Markets to a Downtown Destination
The business began as a cottage food operation, selling baked goods and chocolates at local events and farmers markets. A turning point came through the Downtown Toms River Farmers Market, which introduced Netty’s Sweets to a wider audience and paved the way to a permanent storefront inside the Downtown Shops @ 53 Main Street.
Today, the shop reflects the same warmth that defined its early days. Designed to feel inviting and charming, the space has been compared to a hidden sweet shop you might stumble upon in a coastal town. Late hours during downtown events and active participation in local happenings reinforce the shop’s role as part of the fabric of Toms River.
Why Customers Choose Netty’s Sweets
Customers choose Netty’s Sweets because the experience feels personal from the moment they walk in. The products are crafted with care, the flavors are distinctive, and the atmosphere is welcoming. Unlike large candy chains, this is a shop where feedback matters, recipes evolve, and familiar faces are remembered.
For those searching for a candy store in Toms River, a chocolate shop in Ocean County, or handmade chocolates in New Jersey, Netty’s Sweets offers something rare: consistency, creativity, and heart in every piece.
Stop in, explore the cases, and discover why Netty’s Sweets continues to earn its reputation as one of the most loved candy stores in New Jersey.